Thursday, January 27, 2011 - the "did you miss me" edition?

Hello there - have not posted in a little bit - I hope that somehow you were able to lead productive lives in the meantime......

1. The "So-Called Right of Return" - On January 18, Halifax Herald columnist Paul Schneidereit published a column entitled "Jerusalem: the Israel-Palestinian conflict's Gordian knot" (I cannot seem to find a "live link" to refer you to).

In any event, Dr. Zayid, a local and shall we say, "ardent" pro-Palestinian advocate, took exception when in his column, Mr. Schneidereit referred to the "so-called right of return". Dr. Zayid wrote the following letter to the Herald:
"Fundamental right

Paul Schneidereit, in his Jan. 18 column, makes a derisive comment about the right of return of the Palestinian refugees, calling it "the so-called right of return." The right of return of the Palestinian refugees to their homes is a fundamental right enshrined in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and the UNGA Resolution 194, which was passed on Dec. 11, 1948.

It "resolves that the refugees wishing to return to their homes and live at peace with their neighbours should be permitted to do so at the earliest practicable date." This resolution has been reaffirmed, during the last 62 years, more than 100 times. Yet, sadly, this practicable date has not been allowed to be implemented, due to Israel’s predetermined policy of ethnic cleansing and dispossession.

It should be pointed out that Israel’s admission to the UN, as per UNGA Resolution 273 of May 11, 1949, was conditional on the basis of the implementation of this very resolution.

Ismail Zayid, Halifax"
I have submitted the following reply, though as yet it has not been published:
"To the Editor:

A careful analysis by an objective reader of the relevant United Nations Resolutions, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, the Geneva Conventions, and the like will make it clear that there is no legally binding “fundamental right of return”.

Palestinian advocates often refer to the U.N. General Assembly's 1948 Resolution 194(III), which called for permitting refugees to return to their "homes," as legal support for an alleged "right of return" to Israel. Contrary to this, however, Resolution 194(III), like all other UNGA Resolutions, is nonbinding and not part of international law. Moreover, it was specifically rejected not only by Israel but also by all Arab states, which voted against it because in their eyes, it did not create a right of return and because generally the Resolution was insufficiently anti-Israel.

Further, it is disingenuous for Palestinian advocates to assert the existence of a fundamental right of return while never mentioning that it would necessarily also apply to the hundreds of thousands of Jews who, in the wake of the creation of the State of Israel, were forced to leave the Arab countries where they had lived for centuries, leaving behind billions of dollars in assets.

The resolution of the claims of all true refugees – Arab and Jewish – must be comprised in a political solution to the entire Arab-Israeli conflict."
2. A Truly Amazing Story - A week or so ago, our community had the pleasure of hosting Judie Oron. Judy's CV is chock full of achievements, but I would suggest that her greatest achievement was the decision by her and her sons to adopt two Ethiopian Jewish teenage girls - one of whom Judie had to actually physically rescue by traveling to Ethiopia during the height of a civil war and "purchase" from slavery.

I cannot really do justice to Judie's story, and would refer you to her website - http://www.judieoron.com/ - and suggest that you buy the book (no, I do not get a commission!).

But before I leave the topic, I would point out 2 things that Judy noted in her remarks. First, the world press likes to portray the Mossad, the IDF and other Israeli security forces as ruthless warriors and assassins. While I will not deal with that issue here, I will note that Judy told us that these same security forces were deeply involved in the rescue of thousands of Ethiopian Jews - at great risk to their personal safety. Second, this is the first time in history that a first-world nation removed an indigenous population from their homeland, not to exploit them - but to rescue them.


3. Seismic Activity #1 - Throughout the Arab world, the natives are restless. Starting with the "Jasmine Revolution" in Tunisia, which caused Tunisian ruler Zine El Abidine Ben Ali to flee to Saudi Arabia, the political unrest has spread to Egypt and Yemen. I imagine that there are a lot of very anxious rulers in the area these days. If regime changes result, the big question is what leadership will replace them and what will their policies be - Analysis: A warning to Arab dictators and ‘We’re living on a volcano,’ experts warn?

I am concerned of course, with the impact on relations with Israel - especially as it relates to Egypt and Jordan, which whom Israel has peace treaties. Here are links to a variety of stories on these potentially enormous developments:
As an aside, something that will stated frequently in the coming days is about the role of social media like Twitter and Facebook in these "uprisings" - here is a very interesting article to the contrary by Malcolm Gladwell, author of such books as "Blink", "Outliers" and "The Tipping Point" - Twitter, Facebook, and social activism: newyorker.com - I thought that the article was extremely interesting and well worth the read.


4. Seismic Activity #2 - Things are also very volatile in Lebanon, where Hezbollah stands armed to the teeth - courtesy of such peace loving nations as Syria and Iran - with thousands of missiles aimed at every part of Israel they can target. As reported in my previous postings, the Lebanese government has been toppled (of course it's Israel's fault - Nasrallah: US and Israel caused Lebanese gov't collapse) over the issue of the international probe into the assassination of late Lebanese Prime Minister Rafik Hariri - ‘Khamenei ordered Hariri killing, Hizbullah takeover'

The new Prime Minister selected by Hezbollah says he is committed to ties with the US - New Lebanon PM Mikati says he's committed to US ties - but I am very concerned about any person that Hezbollah deems suitable for the post - New Lebanon PM Mikati says he's committed to US ties. This is a development that bears close scrutiny.



5. The SS St. Louis - in 2009, the Atlantic Jewish Council partnered with The Maritime Museum of the Atlantic to create a very moving and educational exhibit recounting the tragic tale of the SS St. Louis - the so-called "Voyage of the Damned". Here is a link to the exhibit.

Last week, at Pier 21, Canada's Immigration Museum - world-famous architect Daniel Libeskind unveiled his historical monument "Wheels of Conscience". The monument is part of a project by the Canadian Jewish Congress to educate Canadians about the St. Louis incident and its impact on Canada's society and immigration history - here is an excellent column on the subject by Professor Irving Abella - Confronting our dark past - The Globe and Mail


What is especially amazing to me is that Mr. Libeskind, a child of Polish survivors of the Shoah, immigrated to Canada through Pier 21, and then returns all these years later, having achieved such phenomenal success, to unveil this important monument at that same spot where he entered Canada.


6. International Holocaust Day - Today, January 27, is International Holocaust Remembrance Day - as distinct from Yom HaShoah, this is a day mandated by the United Nations and selected to coincide with the Russian liberation of Auschwitz-Birkenau on January 27, 1945 - here are some relevant and related links:

7. The Palestinian Papers - Another major news story this past week or so was the release of a massive dump of documents relative to the Palestinian-Israeli peace "process". The upshot of the documents, released by al-Jazeera, is of course to show how reasonable the Palestinians have been, the major concessions they have made, the intransigence of the Israelis, and that ultimately, the failure of that process is at Israel's feet.

Here are a variety of links from a variety of perspectives:
8. I Had To Read This Twice - to believe that it was real - UN chief condemns rights expert's 9/11 comments - UN Watch - it's about time someone exposed Richard Falk for what he is - a dangerous and biased phony.







12. Iran #1 - The Mullahs and their stooges must love all the instability in the region because it focuses attention elsewhere. But we can't divert our attention from this very serious issue:

15. Open Mouth, Reinsert Feet - Wow.......


16. Jonathan Pollard - For whatever reason, this is an issue I have never explored in depth. Maybe now that it's in the news again, I will take the time to do so - Pollard didn’t harm US, says former US deputy A-G


17. Photography - a hobby I would love to cultivate - all I can say is that it's a good thing there is digital photography these days - I usually need to take 10 shots to get one I like. In any event, here are a couple of links about Soviet photographers and the history they witnessed - Eastern Exposure and Behind the Lens.

18. NFL - Here is a tremendous play by 338 pound defensive tackle BJ Raji from the Packers' victory over the Bears in the NFC Championship. That's right - a 338 pound defensive tackle - not a 200 pound defensive back. And Raji obviously knows how to celebrate. Go Pack!

Posted by at

4 comments:

  1. AnonymousJanuary 28, 2011 at 5:08 AM

    Here is the link to the article in 1. Article was called:
    Jerusalem, the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict's Gordian Knot
    http://thechronicleherald.ca/Opinion/1222512.html

    ReplyDelete
  2. AnonymousJanuary 28, 2011 at 5:43 AM

    Isn't it suspicious that civil unrest has taken place in Egypt, Tunisia and now there are rumblings in Jordan, while Gaza is quiet,and that a quiet takeover has taken place by Hesbollah in Lebanon? The new leader who ousted Hariri whike he was out of the country, has presented himself as a civilized rational man who seeks the unification of Christians with Muslims just happens to be financed by Iran? Hariri, Mubarek, and Hussein in Jordan are all supported by the U.S. so is it any wonder that the winds are shifting? Why Egyptians have chosen this precise time to start a revolution is not a coincidence. Let us not be fooled that this is about an an inevitable reaction to dictatorships,--- this is a deliberate distraction away from the bigger Middle Eastern takeover orchestrated by Iran.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Mark's Pro-Israel BlogJanuary 28, 2011 at 9:50 AM

    I found the link above in the first comment, but it leads to a dead end

    ReplyDelete
  4. wheelchairsFebruary 1, 2011 at 7:04 AM

    I really appreciate your post and you explain each and every point very well.Thanks for sharing this information.And I’ll love to read your next post too.

    ReplyDelete

While you are free to disagree with something I have said or posted, you must not use inappropriate language - comments that are profane, racist or otherwise objectionable will not be tolerated.

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)