Monday, April 12, 2010 - Yom HaShoah

Yom HaShoah - Holocaust Memorial Day - is observed on 27 Nissan on the Hebrew calendar, (this year corresponding to Sunday evening April 11 and Monday April 12). In Halifax, a program was held at 7:30 Sunday evening at the Maritime Museum of the Atlantic on Lower Water Street in Halifax (more about that in tomorrow's postings). In recognition of this important day, today's posting will focus on the Shoah.

Please note that the material below is not intended in any way to be a detailed analysis of the Shoah - it is simply an extremely broad overview for general consumption.

1. Overview - Here is a useful historical overview of the Shoah - The Holocaust - Historical Overview.


2. Why Do You Call It The "Shoah" Instead Of The Holocaust? - Here's why:
Shoa (השואה), also spelled Shoah and Sho'ah, Hebrew for "Destruction", is the Hebrew term for the Holocaust. It is used by many Jews and a growing number of Christians due to theological discomfort with the literal meaning of the word Holocaust; it is considered theologically offensive to imply that the Jews of Europe were a sacrifice to God. It is nonetheless recognized that most people who use the term Holocaust do not intend such a meaning. Similarly, many Roma (Gypsy) people use the word Porajmos, meaning "Devouring" to describe the Nazi attempt to exterminate that group.
3. Thing To Remember #1- The Shoah was not a monolithic event. In other words, it did not occur the same way in all countries. For example, compare the situation in Holland, where an extremely high percentage of Jews were deported and murdered, to that of Bulgaria, where the Jewish population after the War was about the same as it was prior to the War - and Bulgaria was an ally of Germany!

4. The Beginning - In my opinion, the Shoah started with the systematic manner in Nazi Germany that resulted in Jews being dehumanized and pushed to, and then beyond, the edges of German society. This was done in strictly legal terms - at least the law as it existed in Nazi Germany. At that point, it became very easy to then proceed to the next step of extermination. This period of time included such infamous laws as:
"The Law For The Restoration of the Professional Civil Service"
The first major law to curtail the rights of Jewish citizens was the "Law for the Restoration of the Professional Civil Service" of April 7, 1933, according to which Jewish and "politically unreliable" civil servants and employees were to be excluded from state service. The new Civil Service Law was the German authorities' first formulation of the so-called Aryan Paragraph, a kind of regulation used to exclude Jews (and often by extension other "non-Aryans") from organizations, professions, and other aspects of public life.
The so-called "Nuremberg Laws"
The first law, "The Law for the Protection of German Blood and German Honor", prohibited marriages and extra-marital intercourse between “Jews ” (the name was now officially used in place of “non-Aryans ”) and “Germans ” and also the employment of “German ” females under forty-five in Jewish households. The second law, "The Reich Citizenship Law" stripped Jews of their German citizenship and introduced a new distinction between “Reich citizens ” and “nationals.”
The promulgation of these laws were followed in 1938 by Kristallnacht- the infamous Night of Broken Glass - a full-fledged and Nazi Government inspired pogrom against the Jews of Germany. Here is a link to the USHMM online material about this terrible day in Jewish history.


5. The Middle, Part 1 - In September 1939, Nazi Germany invaded Poland. It routed the over matched and under-armed Polish Army in short order. Under the infamous Ribbentrop-Molotov Pact, the Soviet Union invaded the eastern part of Poland and the country was torn in two. The Jews living in the western part of Poland were under Nazis control. As the Wehrmacht moved through Poland, it was followed by "Einsatzgruppen" - special action squads who were to liquidate Jews, Polish intellectuals and other undesirables. When the Nazis in turn invaded the Soviet Union in 1941, the Jews in the former eastern part of Poland as well as Jews in the western parts of the Soviet Union were targeted by the same notorious death squads. It is estimated that some 1.5 million people were brutally murdered by mobile killing squads - such as, for example, the Babi Yar massacre of some 34,000 Jews over a 2 day period in September 1941.


6. The Middle, Part 2 - For a variety of reasons - none of which were in any fashion humanitarian - the Nazis found that exterminating the enormous numbers of Jews who had fallen under Nazi control as a result of the initially seemingly endless Nazi victories in the East via the Einsatzgruppen route was taking too long, was inefficient (it used too much ammunition, for example), and negatively impacted the morale of their troops.

This eventually led to the Wansee Conference held in January 1942 in the posh Berlin suburb of the same name. In this brief meeting (lasting about an hour), the fate of millions of Jews was settled as being essentially worked to death, with those unable to work being marked for immediate death. The purpose of the meeting was to coordinate all the various German governmental agencies that were necessary to conduct the Final Solution.

Part of the result of this Conference was the construction of the so-called Operation Reinhard death camps - named in honor of Reinhard Heydrich - chief of the RHSA (the Reich Main Security Office). These camps were Auschwitz, Treblinka, Belzec and Sobibor. Millions of Jews died in these camps.


And take a moment an consider this - while Nazi Germany is fighting an exhausting 2 front war - in approximately a 2 -3 year period it diverts resources to not only build these extermination camps, but organize and perpetrate the murder millions of Jews. Compare that with the notion that today in Halifax, it takes months to repair two lanes of the Fairview Overpass. This will give one insight into the zeal with which the Nazis pursued the Final Solution.

Oh, and by the way, the despicable Heydrich was assassinated in Prague by two Czechs who had been trained by the British SOE and parachuted into Nazi Europe.

7. The End - By 1944-1945, as the Allies were pressing into Germany from all sides, the extermination of the Jews continued. For example, the deportation and murder of hundreds of thousands of Hungarian Jews occurred within a short period of time starting in the spring and summer of 1944. But even as the death camps were overrun (Auschwitz in January of 1945 for example) - the Nazis herded the surviving Jews back into the Third Reich on notorious death marches.


World War II in Europe ended in May, 1945, though the terrible suffering of the remaining Jews did not cease - whether due to displacement and disease, or to complete indifference on their return to what was left of their homes. There was even an infamous pogrom in Kielce, Poland, in 1946.

8. Thing to Remember #2 - Approximately 1,500,000 children died in the Shoah.


9. Thing to Remember #3 - not only was the Shoah a terrible exercise in organized, state-sponsored mass murder - it was also an exercise in organized, state-sponsored plunder of the assets of the victims - for example, see this link. An excellent book on the subject is Hitler's Beneficiaries.

10. Thing to Remember #4 - while I have recited a variety of statistics in terms of numbers murdered etc, - every victim was a individual person - Unto Every Person There Is A Name

Everyone has a name

Everyone has a name given to him by God and given to him by his parents Everyone has a name given to him by his stature and the way he smiles and given to him by his clothing Everyone has a name given to him by the mountains and given to him by the walls Everyone has a name given to him by the stars and given to him by his neighbors Everyone has a name given to him by his sins and given to him by his longing Everyone has a name given to him by his enemies and given to him by his love Everyone has a name given to him by his holidays and given to him by his work Everyone has a name given to him by the seasons and given to him by his blindness Everyone has a name given to him by the sea and given to him by his death.

Zelda


11. Thing to Remember #5 - While many stood by, there were certain righteous gentiles among the nations who risked their lives to shelter and save Jews. There are commemorated in the Garden Of The Righteous at Yad Vashem


12. Thing to Remember #6 - I believe that we all owe a duty to remember the victims of the Shoah and to act strongly to ensure that no such similar event ever happens again. Tragically, that dream is as yet unfulfilled, as since 1945 there have been numerous genocides and attempts at genocide - the most prominent being in Rwanda, Darfur and the Balkans. This does not detract from our duty to speak up. Remember the famous words of the controversial German Pastor Niemoller:
When the Nazis came for the communists, I remained silent; I was not a communist.
When they locked up the social democrats, I remained silent; I was not a social democrat.
When they came for the trade unionists,I did not speak out; I was not a trade unionist.
When they came for the Jews, I remained silent; I wasn't a Jew.
When they came for me, there was no one left to speak out.
13. Thing to Remember #7 - While we must never forget, we must not let our identity as Jews be defined by the Shoah, or any other Jewish tragedy. Read this (written by a former Catholic priest) and you will see what I mean.


15. Books About The Shoah - I have read a large number of books about the Shoah - a sampling of some that struck me the deepest are shown below.





16. Holocaust Denial - In my opinion, some of the most odious "people" on the planet are those who deny the Shoah. This list includes some infamous people as David Irving, Paul Rassinier, Robert Faurisson, Arthur Butz and, sadly, Canadians such as James Keegstra, Ernst Zundel and Malcolm Ross. These people and their despicable views must be fought every inch of the way - not only to ensure the memory of the innocent victims, but also of the millions of Allied service personnel who fought and died to defeat Nazi fascism.


17. Movies About The Shoah - Everyone is familiar with such films as Schindler's List, The Pianist, and Life Is Beautiful. I am sure that there are many other that I am unfamiliar with (please let me know the names of other films). People have varying opinions as to the accuracy of such films. I find them important if only because they bring the whole issue of the Shoah to the fore. An excellent documentary to watch is Auschwitz: Inside the Nazi State

18. Conclusion - I try to end my postings with something upbeat or positive. I will not do so today. But I will urge you to do your own research and education about the Shoah - don't take what I said for granted. Learn about the Shoah, and teach your children and your friends. It is the very least that each one of us can do.

"Take heed... lest you forget the things your eyes have seen... and tell them to your children, and their children after them" (Deut. 4:9)

Friday, April 9, 2010


1. Those Darn Israelis - the following column appeared in last Saturday's Halifax paper. I did not notice it at first, but thankfully, a friend brought it to my attention.
LETTER REMOVED AT REQUEST OF AUTHOR

I was absolutely outraged over the comments he made about Israel, and penned the following original reply (I include the whole reply because of the factual information in it):
To The Editor:

While I can accept legitimate criticism of the policies of the Israeli government, I have seldom read something as offensive and uninformed in the pages of the Chronicle-Herald as Jack Warkentin’s rambling rant published in Saturday’s edition.

His assertion that Israel seized Palestinian land through terrorism is simply astounding. The breadth of his comment leaves me to wonder whether he is referring to the formation of Israel in 1948, or its capture of Egyptian, Syrian and Jordanian controlled territory (not Palestinian) in 1967.

If the former, then perhaps he should consider that the State of Israel was founded on lands designated for the Jews of Palestine by the 1947 UN Partition Resolution that divided the former Ottoman Empire lands governed by the British Mandate - the original two state solution. While liked by neither Jews nor Arabs, the Partition Resolution was accepted by the Jews and rejected by the Arabs. On the declaration of the State of Israel some 6 months later in 1948, it was immediately attacked by 6 Arab armies. The lands designated for the Arabs ended up in the control of Egypt (Gaza) and Jordan (the West Bank).

If the latter, then perhaps Mr. Warkentin might do some study of the Six Day War in 1967. After closing the Straits of Tiran (an act of war in and of itself), Egypt and Syria very publicly planned to attack and destroy Israel, and coerced Jordan into joining. The result was a victory for the Israelis that left them in control of Sinai, Gaza and the West Bank. Having been defeated militarily, the Arab diplomatic reaction was to hold the Khartoum Conference in September 1967, after which the Arab countries famously pledged the "Three Nos" - no peace with Israel, no recognition of it, and no negotiations with it. Six years later, Egypt and Syria launched a devastating attack on Israel on the holiest day of the Jewish year.

But what is truly breathtaking is his suggestion that the Israeli refusal to negotiate a just peace with the Palestinians is the "root cause of much of the world’s hostilities". Ignoring any questions of Palestinian responsibility for the current morass, Mr. Warkentin is apparently building upon a recent statement to the same effect attributed to US General Petraeus - which, by the way, General Petraeus has emphatically denied making.

But let’s examine this ridiculous allegation further. To which hostilities does he refer? The Russian-Georgian dispute? The Russian-Chechen dispute? The war in the Congo that leaves 45,000 people dead
every month? The tensions between North & South Korea, between India and Pakistan, or China and Taiwan? Afghanistan? Shia and Sunni Muslims murdering each other all over the globe? Sure - it must be Israel’s fault!

Natan Sharansky, the former Soviet dissident and current Israeli politician, advocates the so-called "3D Test" in determining whether criticism of Israel is legitimate or amounts to antisemitism. The three prongs of the test are "double standards, demonization and delegitimization". On those grounds, Mr. Warkentin’s comments are clearly antisemitic.

In closing, I have no idea who Mr. Warkentin is, nor why he is qualified or permitted to express such comments in print. However, the serious issues of the Israeli-Palestinian interaction deserve much better.

For a variety of reasons, the Editor was not prepared to print the entire response, though it did agree to consider printing a scaled-down version. Here is the final version I submitted - I hope it gets published:
To The Editor:
I have seldom read something as offensive and uninformed as Jack Warkentin’s anti-Israel rant published in last Saturday’s newspaper.

Limited space does not allow me to reply to his allegations about Israel seizing or control of Palestinian lands. I will focus instead on his assertion that Israel’s refusal to negotiate a just peace with the Palestinians (which ignores any questions of Palestinian responsibility) is the "root cause of much of the world’s hostilities".

To which hostilities does he refer? To name but a few - the Russian-Georgian dispute? The Russian-Chechen dispute? The war in the Congo that leaves 45,000 people dead every month? The Sudanese Civil War and the humanitarian catastrophe in Darfur? The civil war in Somalia that has reduced that country to a lawless no-man’s land? The tensions between North and South Korea, India and Pakistan, or China and Taiwan? Afghanistan? Shia and Sunni Muslims murdering each other all over the globe? Mr. Warkentin would have readers believe that if only Israel would make peace with the Palestinians, all of these problems would simply vanish - a truly breathtaking assertion.

Natan Sharansky, the former Soviet dissident and current Israeli politician, advocates the so-called "3D Test" in determining whether criticism of Israel is legitimate or amounts to antisemitism. The three prongs of the test are "double standards, demonization and delegitimization". On those grounds, Mr. Warkentin’s comment is clearly antisemitic.

The serious issues of the Israeli-Palestinian interaction deserve much better analysis.




4. Another Of The Big Lies - alleged dual loyalty, that is - Pajamas Media » Dennis Ross and Dual Loyalties


5. Before You Open Your Mouth - Think - someone please tell me how this makes any sort of sense - Parade of horribles




8. Comedy & Human Rights Follow-Up - Enter the comedy police



10. Funny Picture Of The Day - Boy, can a high speed camera make you look silly!

Wednesday, April 7, 2010 - Happy Chametz!!

I'm back after the Passover break - glad to be eating chametz again.....Now, down to business. I apologize that some of this may be "old" news, but I am catching up on the things I did not blog about over the Passover break.

(see you next year)

1. Attack in Moscow - Blast on Moscow subway kills dozens World News Ottawa Sun. Gee, I sure hope that the Russians don't over-react and take any disproportionate measures. I can see that by Vladimir Putin's language - quoted here - that everything will be done according to Hoyle. Oh and by the way, why did the reporters make reference to "terror attacks" and the like - don't they know that these are just attacks by "militants" - oh, that's just against Israel.


2. Must Be The Fog Of War - Gaza youth returns home alive



- meanwhile, Rome burns, so to speak



8. The World's Gone Nuts #6 - Muslim students call for removal of "year of Our Lord" from diplomas at... Trinity University - Jihad Watch. Uh, guys, it's "Trinity" University - shouldn't you sort of expect that? Even I know what The Trinity is, and I'm Jewish.










14. The World's Gone Nuts #12 - Sensitivity: A one-way street


16. It Could Not Happen Here - Does the story above lead to this? Machete used in anti-Semitic attack in Gatineau, Carleton students say and Adrian MacNair: An isolated incident, using a machete - Full Comment. Hey - (sarcasm on) do you think that University spokesman went too far with his comment? (sarcasm off). Not acceptable? Got anything more pointed?

“The Israel and Palestine issue is one of the things that can cause people to become emotional,” MacDonald said. “Our job is to make sure that these debates can happen without anyone’s personal safety being threatened.

“We have met with student groups on both sides of such issues and told them that we are not here to tell them what to think, but certain kinds of behaviour are not acceptable" (my emphasis)


18. NCAA Championship - Monday evening, Duke beat Butler 61-59 in a tremendous final game. Kudos to both teams on an excellent game - Duke - the blueblood elite school with 3 prior championships and Butler - the "mid-major" school from Indianapolis (6 miles from the site of the championship game) which plays its home games at Hinkle Fieldhouse - the famous arena from the movie "Hoosiers".


Here is the video of the last-second desperate attempt by Butler star Gordon Hayward for a game-winning three point shot:


Also, kudos to the UConn Huskies female basketball team, which won its 78th game in a row and captured its second straight NCAA women's basketball championship.


Monday, March 29, 2010

To readers who celebrate Passover - Chag Pesach Sameach

(this is not a picture of me - I do not have as much hair)


To readers who celebrate Easter - Happy Easter


To everyone else - Happy "Whatever"



Saturday, March 27, 2010 - motzei Shabbat

1. Diplomatic 101 - So the Obama Administration reacted with outrage when the construction plan for 1600 East Jerusalem apartments was announced when Vice-President Biden was in Israel. The President himself was said to be "incandescent with rage" (though he somehow cooled himself off sufficiently so that he did not get upset at the PA's dedication (during Biden's visit) of a town square to the terrorist who led the bloodiest terror attack on Israel in its history, nor when rockets from Gaza killed a foreign worker in Israel while the EU's top diplomat was in Israel and Gaza - very admirable.....), and he dispatched Secretary of State Clinton and Senior Adviser David Axelrod to publicly rip Israel.


So to show the maturity and sophistication of his Administration when it comes to these types of diplomatic matters, what does the President do when Israeli PM Netanyahu is in Washington for the AIPAC Convention? He walks out on a meeting with Netanyahu to take a private meal - call me if there are any developments?


Can anyone see the President doing this with the Saudi King, Egyptian President Mubarak, Jordanian King Abdullah, or any European, North American, South American or Asian leader (other than the leaders of North Korea, Iran and maybe Syria)?

Are you kidding me? Even the President should know that two wrongs do not make a right - or maybe they do, except that "right" is spelled "Wright" - in homage to the atrocious Reverend Jeremiah Wright who preached anti-American and antisemitic bile at the President's church in Chicago for years and years - though of course the President never noticed anything amiss.



In any event, this was a terrible move on the part of the Administration. It shows a stunning lack of tact and diplomacy. It gives a terrible signal to Israel's enemies that the Administration is prepared to hang Israel out to dry - demanding more and more concessions from Israel (which he knows that once made, will be honored) while asking nothing from the PA or the Arabs - who give nothing and ask for more from Israel. It gives a terrible signal to the right wing of Israeli politics - that the USA is going to throw Israel under the bus (where they will meet a lot of people, maybe even Reverend Wright) so that Israel should just do what it wishes.


Given his ego and bias, and that of his advisors and colleagues, the President may think that all of this is OK because the USA does not need Israel for anything. He'll be sorry for this stance - whether it will be tomorrow, next week, next month or next year. But it may be too late then.




5. Let Me Make Myself Perfectly Clear - An elderly ex-Nazi who admitted to participating in the murder of 3 Dutchmen during World War II as reprisal for attacks on German soldiers in Holland will not face jail time for his crime. As far as I am concerned, all the Nazi war criminals should be treated in the exact same way that they treated their victims, regardless of age or gender. I have read a tremendous amount of material about the Shoah -I have never come across a case where a Nazi soldier said - "oh, let's not murder this old (or young) Jew because of their age). Pajamas Media » German Court Lets Admitted Nazi Murderer Go Free - I hope you choke on your pablum, you Nazi bastard - and that your death is slow and as agonizing as possible. Then - enjoy Hell.

GO DIRECTLY TO JAIL YOU NAZI BASTARD


7. "Moderate" Muslims - Pajamas Media » Silencing the Jews


8. University of Ottawa - The Coulter fallout continues. The University Administration might consider looking at item 10 below.
9. A Passover Message For Today - Chesler Chronicles

10. Testemax - warning - this is an off-color video - or as they say on our local TV channel before every episode of The Family Guy - "Warning. This video contains coarse language and mature subject matter. Viewer Discretion is advised."